2025 Honda Civic
⭐ 5-Star NHTSA From $23,950 MSRPFuel Economy
36/46 MPG
Safety Rating
5-Star NHTSA
Driver Assist
Honda Sensing
- Honda Sensing standard on all trims
- #1 reliability in class
- Low insurance cost
- No AWD option
- Rear seat tight for adults
Safety & Value · 2025
Best First Cars for Teens in 2025
The best first car balances safety, reliability, and low ownership costs. We ranked the 6 top picks that hit all three — with real NHTSA crash ratings and standard driver-assist features.
2025 Toyota Corolla
⭐ 5-Star NHTSA From $22,050 MSRPFuel Economy
32/42 MPG
Safety Rating
5-Star NHTSA
Driver Assist
Safety Sense 3.0
- Best long-term reliability record
- Toyota Safety Sense 3.0 standard
- Lowest insurance rates in class
- Less engaging to drive
- CVT only
2025 Mazda3 Sedan
⭐ 5-Star NHTSA From $23,450 MSRPFuel Economy
26/35 MPG
Safety Rating
5-Star NHTSA
Driver Assist
i-Activsense
- Premium interior feel above price point
- Sharpest handling in class
- Strong safety suite
- Rear seat space limited
- No AWD on base trims
2025 Subaru Impreza
⭐ 5-Star NHTSA From $23,995 MSRPFuel Economy
28/38 MPG
Safety Rating
5-Star NHTSA
Driver Assist
EyeSight
- Symmetrical AWD standard
- EyeSight driver assist standard
- Excellent crash test scores
- Base audio quality
- Firm suspension
2025 Hyundai Elantra
⭐ 5-Star NHTSA From $21,775 MSRPFuel Economy
33/43 MPG
Safety Rating
5-Star NHTSA
Driver Assist
SmartSense
- Feature-rich at base price
- SmartSense safety suite standard
- 5yr/60k powertrain warranty
- Firm ride quality
- Road noise on highway
2025 Nissan Sentra
⭐ 5-Star NHTSA From $20,290 MSRPFuel Economy
29/39 MPG
Safety Rating
5-Star NHTSA
Driver Assist
Safety Shield 360
- Most affordable on list
- Safety Shield 360 standard
- Spacious interior
- Underpowered 149hp engine
- No AWD option
Not sure what car fits your teen's needs?
Tell Scout your budget and priorities. We'll match you to the safest, most affordable options — no pressure, no dealership games.